Picking a business card printer sounds simple until you actually try to order. Suddenly you are staring at paper weights, finishes, coatings, and more templates than you knew existed. If you are comparing Vistaprint vs Jukebox business cards, you are basically choosing between “cheap and easy” and “premium and experimental.”
In this review, I will walk through how Vistaprint and Jukebox handle design, materials, pricing, and overall experience, with clear pros and cons for each. The short version: Vistaprint is better for budget business cards with lots of professional looking templates, while Jukebox is for people who care more about unique stocks and high end finishes and are willing to pay for them.
A business card is tiny, but it says a lot. The paper, finish, and design all send a message before anyone reads your name.
TLDR
If you’re torn between Vistaprint and Jukebox Print for custom business cards, you’re really choosing between two different priorities:
- Vistaprint: budget friendly, lots of professional templates, “good and polished” with minimal effort.
- Jukebox: fewer templates, but unique and fun options with premium materials that can feel very high-end—and cost a lot more.
In this article, I’ll walk through how they compare on design tools, materials, pricing, ordering, and overall quality, then wrap up with clear pros and cons for each.
Vistaprint vs Jukebox Print in a nutshell
Vistaprint
- Big online printer focused on affordable, custom business cards and other marketing items.
- Huge template library for different industries and styles.
- Standard 14 pt business cards with matte, gloss, and uncoated options, plus upgrades to thicker and specialty stocks.
- Very low entry pricing and frequent promos.
- Best for: new businesses, side hustles, and anyone who wants decent cards on a tight budget.
Jukebox Print
- Smaller, design-driven printer known for unusual business card stocks.
- Fewer templates; leans more toward people who already have a design or care a lot about materials.
- Offers kraft, bamboo, recycled cards, soft touch, Colorplan colored stocks, and lots of premium finishes.
- Higher price per card, especially on specialty options.
- Best for: designers, creative studios, and brands that care more about a premium feel than saving money.
Design tools and templates
Vistaprint: easy for non-designers
Vistaprint’s biggest strength is how easy it is to get something professional-looking without design skills.
- You can browse thousands of templates organized by industry, style, and theme.
- The online editor lets you drop in your logo, change colors, and edit text quickly.
- You can also upload a full custom design if you already have one.
The overall vibe: clean, corporate, and safe. If you just want a card that looks like it came from a normal print shop and don’t want to overthink it, Vistaprint is a comfortable place to start.
Jukebox: more creative, fewer “plug and play” options
Jukebox does have online design options and some premade layouts, but the experience is more “design-first” and less template-driven.
- Their site leans heavily on inspiration galleries and specialty card examples.
- They expect many customers to upload artwork or work closely with a designer.
- Templates skew more unique and playful, but there aren’t nearly as many as Vistaprint offers.
If you’re not comfortable making design decisions, Jukebox can feel a bit more intimidating. If you already have a strong design or a designer helping you, the limited templates are less of an issue.
Paper stocks, materials, and finishes
This is where the two companies really separate.
Vistaprint: solid range within the “standard” world
Vistaprint covers most of what a typical business needs:
- Standard cards: around 14 pt cardstock, with matte, glossy, or uncoated finishes.
- Premium and Premium Plus cards: thicker stocks (around 18 pt and up) with nicer feel and options like square formats or rounded corners.
- Special finishes: raised/embossed gloss, foil accents, and alternative shapes like square or circle cards.
So Vistaprint gives you a wide menu, but almost everything still lives in the “conventional business card” universe—white cardstocks, familiar coatings, and simple upgrades.
Jukebox: experimental and premium materials
Jukebox is built around unusual, tactile stocks and high-end processes. Examples include:
- Soft touch cards with a thick, velvety surface.
- Bamboo cards in 18 pt and 36 pt, biodegradable and eco-friendly.
- Kraft cards with a natural brown, recycled look.
- Colorplan cards in bold, colored stocks with a luxe uncoated finish and optional white ink.
- Recycled and specialty stocks, often shown in sample packs that highlight soft touch, recycled, spot gloss, kraft, and more.
- Advanced processes like foil stamping, spot gloss, edge coloring, die-cutting, letterpress, and duplex (two-ply) cards.
This is the big reason people pay more for Jukebox: your card can feel unlike anything coming out of a typical online printer.
Pricing and value
Pricing changes with promos, but the relationship between the two brands is consistent.
Vistaprint pricing
Vistaprint’s standard business cards are set up to be very cheap to get into:
- Standard cards often start at 50 cards for around $10.
- Basic 100-card runs are typically well under what Jukebox charges.
- They run frequent sales and coupon codes, especially around big shopping periods.
Some of the nicer finishes do cost more, and once you pile on upgrades the gap narrows. But if you want basic, decent cards as cheaply as possible, Vistaprint usually wins by a wide margin.
Jukebox pricing
Jukebox sits firmly in the premium camp:
- Standard cards are usually around $40+ for 100.
- Soft touch and other specialty cards often start in a similar or slightly higher range for 100.
- Complex builds (like multi-process, die-cut, foil, edge-painted cards) can climb quickly.
Per card, you’re often paying several times what you’d pay at Vistaprint. The trade-off is that you get stocks and finishes that look and feel like high-end boutique work.
If you only need a small batch and want maximum impact, that can be worth it. If you need 1,000 cards for a sales team, the price difference adds up fast.
Ordering experience and turnaround
Vistaprint: streamlined and familiar
Vistaprint is geared toward people who want to get in, design, and check out fast.
- The interface is straightforward, especially for template-based designs.
- Reordering past designs is simple.
- They offer multiple shipping speeds, and production is fairly predictable for standard jobs.
If you’ve used any big online print service before, Vistaprint will feel familiar.
Jukebox: more control, more complexity
With Jukebox, the ordering flow can be more involved:
- There are more decisions to make about stock, thickness, coating, and special processes.
- Some configurations require you to read more detailed specs, especially for advanced finishes.
- They emphasize quality checks and offer rush options on certain stocks.
If you enjoy dialing in every detail, this is a plus. If you just want “nice cards, quickly,” the extra complexity might feel like overkill.
Print quality and brand impression
Both services can deliver sharp, professional cards—but the impression they give is different.
Vistaprint quality
- Good, reliable print quality for the price.
- Standard stocks feel similar to what you’d expect from a local quick printer.
- Upgraded stocks and finishes can look quite nice, though still within a mass-market feel.
Most people will see a Vistaprint card and think, “Looks professional, no problem.”
Jukebox quality
- Very strong reputation for print accuracy and paper quality.
- Widely recognized in independent reviews and by major outlets as a top business card option, especially in the premium category.
- On the right stock (soft touch, Colorplan, bamboo, etc.), the card feels like a high-end product.
Handing someone a thick, soft touch Jukebox card is a very different experience than handing them a thin, glossy budget card. If your brand leans luxury, design-forward, or eco-conscious, that tactile difference matters.
Pros and cons at a glance
Vistaprint business cards
Pros
- Very low starting prices, especially for standard cards.
- Huge library of professional templates for many industries.
- Easy online editor and simple reordering.
- Wide range of shapes, thicknesses, and finishes for a mainstream printer.
Cons
- Basic cards can feel generic compared to premium or boutique printers.
- Truly standout finishes often require paid upgrades.
- If you rely only on templates, your cards may resemble other businesses using the same designs.
Jukebox Print business cards
Pros
- Excellent selection of unique materials (bamboo, kraft, Colorplan, soft touch, and more).
- Access to high-end processes like foil, spot gloss, letterpress, die-cutting, and edge coloring.
- Strong reputation for premium quality and attention to detail.
- Good fit for creative, luxury, or eco-focused brands that want their card to feel special.
Cons
- Significantly more expensive than Vistaprint for most runs.
- Ordering can feel more complex, especially for custom builds.
- Fewer simple templates; non-designers may need extra time or help.
So, which one should you choose?
If you want affordable, professional business cards with minimal effort, Vistaprint is the clear choice. You get:
- Low pricing
- Tons of templates
- Simple ordering
- Enough upgrades to make your cards look “above basic” if you want
If you want business cards that feel unique and premium, and you’re willing to pay for that, Jukebox Print is hard to beat. You get:
- Unusual and eco-friendly materials
- High-end finishes that stand out
- A more memorable tactile experience
Put simply:
- Choose Vistaprint if budget and convenience are your top priorities.
- Choose Jukebox if you care more about the physical feel and uniqueness of the card than the total cost.