Short context: two premium, design-first card shops
Jukebox Print and Moo are both positioned as premium, design-forward printers rather than budget mills. They sit above the VistaPrint / GotPrint tier on feel and finish, and target people who actually care how a card stock, edge, or foil looks in hand, not just “250 cards as cheap as possible.”
In our internal scoring for premium specialists, Jukebox scores higher on quality and options, while Moo scores higher on templates/tools and customer service. External reviewers back this up: Jukebox has been named one of the best overall business card printing services by major outlets, largely on the strength of its paper stocks and color accuracy. Moo is regularly featured as one of the top choices for stylish, easy-to-design cards.
That context colors how we look at Jukebox vs Moo business cards across quality, price, tools, and use cases.
Quality (Materials and Print)
Jukebox
In our premium table, Jukebox has the top quality score in this group at 5.0 out of 5. That matches what you see in real-world testing. Jukebox prints on a long list of heavyweight, design-grade papers: Colorplan by GF Smith, Mohawk Superfine, Gmund, Neenah, Fedrigoni, plus eco stocks like bamboo, kraft, and recycled options.
The result is less “corporate gloss” and more “studio-grade stationery.” Cards tend to feel dense, with strong ink density and good registration even on fine lines and complex designs. Reviewers praise Jukebox for color accuracy, precise trimming, and thick card stocks that deliver some of the best-looking business cards you can buy online.
Because Jukebox pushes so many specialty options, quality also shows up in how finishes are applied. Spot gloss, foil, duplex/triplex constructions, white ink on dark stocks, and soft touch coatings are all handled at a level that feels more like a boutique print shop than a mass online printer.
Moo
Moo’s quality score in our internal table is 4.5 out of 5, just behind Jukebox but still firmly premium. The company is best known for its Original, Super, and Luxe cards. Luxe uses thick Mohawk Superfine paper in a quadplex construction with a colored core, which many reviewers describe as “bank card thick” and extremely tactile.
Print quality on Moo’s higher-end stocks is excellent: sharp type, good color saturation, and consistent cuts. Where Moo falls slightly behind Jukebox is in sheer variety of card stocks and niche finishes. You get soft touch, high gloss, foils, and a few specialty formats, but not the same “paper playground” feeling that Jukebox offers with bamboo, cork, premium colored stocks, and more obscure finishes.
If you mainly want ultra-thick, bright white cards with a color seam and modern templates, Moo quality is more than enough. If you care about unusual materials, white ink on deep color stocks, or eco specialty papers, Jukebox is ahead.
Verdict on quality: Jukebox is the better choice for stock variety and “paper nerd” projects. Moo is fantastic for thick, bright, modern cards, but just a bit narrower in scope.
Price and Value
Both Jukebox and Moo sit solidly in the premium pricing tier. In our scoring, Jukebox earns a 2.6 for price while Moo gets a 1.5, which basically means “expensive” vs “very expensive” within this comparison set.
Jukebox pricing
Third-party comparisons and card tools typically list Jukebox starting around the mid–$40 range for 250 standard cards, with premium stocks increasing the price. Jukebox’s own promos often show 100 soft touch cards in roughly the mid–$30 range.
So Jukebox is not cheap versus budget printers like GotPrint or Primoprint, but the per-card price comes down quickly at 250 or 500 copies and is often better than Moo for similar thickness and finish.
Moo pricing
Moo is one of the most expensive big-name options. Their marketing and independent guides put baseline cards at around $20 for 50, with Super cards starting in the low $30s for 50 and Luxe cards starting in the low $40s for 50. That translates to a noticeably higher per-card cost than Jukebox for typical quantities, especially if you want Luxe or heavy special finishes.
You are paying for a cohesive design experience and the Mohawk Superfine stocks. For some people that is worth it. For price-sensitive buyers, though, Moo is hard to justify unless the card is a central part of your brand.
Verdict on price: Jukebox is still premium, but generally offers better value per card, especially at 250 and 500 quantities. Moo is the pricier choice in Jukebox vs Moo business cards, with cost justified mainly by the Luxe line and the overall experience.
Design, Templates, and Customization
Jukebox
Historically Jukebox leaned toward designers and print pros. That shows in our scoring: 3.2 for templates and tools, which is “good, not mass-market huge.” They do have a growing template library, a free online business card maker, and integration with tools like Adobe Express, but the default assumption is that you either upload finished files or you are comfortable tweaking semi-pro designs.
On the customization side, Jukebox is incredibly flexible. Colorplan cards with white ink, duplex and triplex constructions, mixed stocks front and back, spot gloss, foil, soft touch, sandy matte, and more are all on the table. If you are willing to read spec sheets and follow print prep guidelines, you can build some very unusual cards.
Moo
Moo scores 4.5 on templates and tools in our table, which matches how most people experience the site. The editor is one of the most user-friendly in the space: drag-and-drop layouts, modern fonts, well-designed templates, and support for simple things like QR codes and logo placement.
Moo’s Printfinity feature also stands out. You can have a different design on the back of every card in a single order, which is a clever trick for photographers, illustrators, agencies, or anyone who wants to show multiple portfolio pieces without paying for multiple SKUs.
The tradeoff is that Moo’s customization paths are a little more constrained than Jukebox. You have a very polished sandbox, but less freedom to specify unusual paper combinations or esoteric finishes.
Verdict on design tools: Moo is better for non-designers and small businesses that want to pick a template, tweak a logo, and be done. Jukebox is better for designers and people who know exactly what they want from stock and finishing.
Customer Service
In our scoring, Moo edges Jukebox slightly on customer service, 5.0 vs 4.0.
Jukebox
Jukebox positions itself as a hybrid of online convenience and hands-on prepress support. Every business card order is reviewed by real staff before printing, and they promote a Customer Success manager and prepress team that will flag issues such as bleed, resolution, or trim problems.
Support is primarily via email and phone during business hours, with strong reviews from design-savvy customers who appreciate human eyes on their files. The main negative you see in external writeups is that complex specialty projects can have more back-and-forth and sometimes longer resolution times, simply because more can go wrong when you are doing foils, duplexing, and unusual stocks.
Moo
Moo’s service reputation is one of their strengths. They are quick to reprint miscut or misprinted orders, and most long-time customers report consistent, helpful interactions when something goes wrong. Industry roundups often highlight Moo as balancing polished tools with responsive support in a way that feels very “consumer-ready.”
There are some scattered complaints online about quality control on very recent runs, but overall they still land in the “reliable premium” tier.
Verdict on service: Moo wins on pure support and ease of escalation, Jukebox is more “print shop that happens to be online,” with deeper file checks and guidance, especially for complex jobs.
Ordering Experience & Tools
Jukebox
The Jukebox ordering flow feels like a modern commercial printer rather than a templated marketplace. The instant pricing tool can handle stock, finish, foil, and other variables in one panel, which is great once you understand the jargon.
For casual users this can be slightly intimidating, but if you are used to thinking in terms of “16 pt matte, soft touch, spot gloss on front, duplex Colorplan” then it is incredibly powerful. Jukebox also offers online design tools so you are not forced to upload a print-ready PDF.
Moo
Moo’s site feels closer to a consumer product configurator. You choose a card type (Original, Super, Luxe, Cotton), pick a template, and then customize it in a very visual editor.
The upside is that almost anyone can get a good looking card with minimal knowledge of print. The downside is that some advanced users find it less flexible or a little constrained once they start trying to push designs beyond the provided grids and options.
Verdict on tools: Moo is friendlier and more approachable. Jukebox wins for power users who want fine control over stock and finishing.
Turnaround Time and Shipping
Our scores reflect what we see in real-world offerings: Jukebox earns 3.0 on turnaround, Moo 2.0.
Jukebox
Jukebox offers fast production on standard cards, often in one to two business days, with same-day options available on certain styles if you order early and are within the right region. Shipping time depends heavily on where you are, since they are headquartered in Canada but serve customers in many countries. For simple North American jobs, total time from order to arrival is respectable for a premium shop.
More complex options, like letterpress-style or heavy duplex cards or intricate foils, can take longer. If you are pushing the envelope on finishes, build in extra time.
Moo
Moo advertises delivery in as few as two business days for some card types and locations, especially in the US and UK. In practice, once you add production plus shipping, Moo tends to feel similar to Jukebox for simple orders and slower than budget printers with overnight options.
Where Moo loses a point in our scoring is that rush options on Luxe or heavy special finishes can become expensive and still not match true “tomorrow morning” speed.
Verdict on speed: For straightforward cards, they are roughly comparable. Jukebox has an edge on production speed relative to other boutique shops, especially for same-day or next-day local printing, while Moo is more middle of the pack for premium services.
Use Cases / Best For
Here is where the choice between Jukebox vs Moo business cards gets practical.
Jukebox – best for:
- Designers, agencies, and studios who already have print-ready files and care deeply about materials and finish.
- Brands that want unusual or eco stocks such as bamboo, kraft, recycled, premium colored papers, or triplex cards with painted edges.
- Complex, high-impact cards where spot gloss, foiling, duplex, or white ink on dark stocks are central to the design.
- Customers who value human prepress review and are willing to trade a small bit of self-serve simplicity for more control.
Moo – best for:
- Solo professionals and small businesses who want their cards to look better than budget printers without doing a full design from scratch.
- People who love ultra-thick cards with a color seam and want that “wow” moment when someone first handles the card.
- Users who want modern templates and a slick editor, where they can experiment visually instead of thinking about bleed and stock specs.
- Creatives who like Printfinity and want different backs on each card in a single pack.
Pros and Cons
Jukebox – Pros
- Top-tier print quality and color accuracy
- Huge range of stocks and finishes, including eco and specialty options
- Very strong reputation among designers and print pros
- Human file checks and detailed prepress support
- Same-day and fast production on many card types
Jukebox – Cons
- Premium pricing compared with budget printers
- Site and options can overwhelm non-designers
- Complex specialty jobs may have longer lead times or more back-and-forth
Moo – Pros
- Excellent templates and one of the best online editors
- Luxe and Super cards feel thick, premium, and memorable
- Strong customer service with generous reprint policies
- Printfinity and other creative features for portfolio-driven work
- Clear, approachable ordering flow for non-designers
Moo – Cons
- Among the most expensive options per card in this category
- Fewer truly exotic paper and finish combinations than Jukebox
- Some recent reports of small QC issues on trimming or color
- Rush production plus shipping can get pricey
Final Verdict / Conclusion
If we go strictly by our internal scores, Jukebox comes out slightly ahead of Moo among premium card specialists, with a higher overall average driven by top marks in quality and options. Moo remains a very strong contender, especially if you care about templates, tools, and thick, modern-feeling cards that are easy to design online.
In plain language:
- Choose Jukebox if materials, finishes, and the physical feel of the card matter most, and you are comfortable either designing your own card or working from more minimal templates.
- Choose Moo if you want a polished online editor, great templates, and ultra-thick cards with less effort, and you are willing to pay for the convenience.
For many designers and “paper people,” Jukebox has become the default premium choice. For people who want an Apple-like design experience and are not as worried about having obscure stock options, Moo is still a very safe pick.