Quick context
All three of these companies specialize in thick vinyl stickers with laminate, aimed at artists, small brands, and anyone who wants stickers that survive on water bottles and laptops. For this sticker blitz vs sticker mule vs customstickers comparison, we combined three inputs:
- Our own test orders and long term use
- The scoring framework we use across sticker companies (quality, price, options, customer service, turnaround)
- Public info from each company’s site plus recent third party reviews and community threads
The short version: all three can produce good looking vinyl. The real differences show up in price, how fast they move, and how much you care about the company behind the stickers.
Quality: materials and print
Sticker Blitz
Sticker Blitz leans hard into thick matte vinyl with a durable laminate. Independent artist reviews often describe their stickers as very thick, waterproof, and dishwasher safe, with quality on par with or even better than bigger names.
Not every experience is perfect. Some detailed comparisons score Sticker Blitz a bit lower on print sharpness, noting slightly fuzzy text on small details, even while praising durability and overall feel.
Net result: sturdy, matte vinyl that holds up well outdoors, with generally strong color and line quality and the occasional report of softer detail.
Sticker Mule
Sticker Mule built its reputation on quality. They print at high resolution on thick vinyl with a protective laminate, and their default die cut stickers are matte and very durable.
Community feedback lines up with that story. Long time customers consistently call out sharp printing and robust stickers that survive dishwashers and daily abuse.
In our own internal scoring, Sticker Mule still sits near the top of the quality column, tied with the best specialists.
Custom Stickers
CustomStickers.com prints on premium vinyl with a weatherproof, UV resistant laminate, often rated for multiple years outdoors.
They run modern wide gamut printers and cut detailed shapes cleanly, which shows up when you look at fine lines or subtle gradients. Our samples have held up to heavy outdoor use and dishwasher cycles without peeling or fading, and that’s consistent with external customer reviews.
In our sticker company table, CustomStickers.com is one of the few to earn a full 5 out of 5 for quality.
Quality verdict: All three brands deliver real vinyl, laminate-coated stickers that feel substantial in hand. Sticker Mule and CustomStickers.com are essentially top tier on consistency, with Sticker Blitz close behind and occasionally even preferred by artists who like their particular matte finish.
Price and value
Sticker Blitz pricing
Sticker Blitz positions itself as high quality at an approachable price. Their site highlights “high quality, thick, waterproof stickers” with fast turnaround and free shipping, along with sample packs so you can check quality first.
Third party price checks generally put them in the mid to upper range per sticker for small runs, for example around a dollar-plus per piece for short die cut runs, which is typical for premium vinyl.
You’re not buying bargain bin stickers here. You’re paying reasonable premium pricing for solid materials and fast service.
Sticker Mule pricing
Sticker Mule is rarely called cheap. Even fans will describe the pricing as expensive but defend it on quality and fast shipping, especially outside big promo windows.
The company is also known for aggressive flash deals and heavily discounted “sample” packs, which can make them feel affordable if you’re flexible on timing and quantity. Without a sale though, Sticker Mule usually ends up near the top of the price range for standard 3 inch die cut stickers among major printers.
In our internal ratings they score very high on quality but much lower on price, reflecting that gap.
CustomStickers.com pricing
CustomStickers.com pitches itself as premium quality with a best price guarantee rather than a “forever on sale” shop. Their sticker pages and blog explicitly promise to match lower published prices on equivalent vinyl stickers and emphasize competitive pricing even on short runs.
In practice, when we compare like-for-like sizes and quantities, CustomStickers.com almost always beats Sticker Mule and often lands below or equal to other specialists, especially once you factor in free shipping. That’s why they earn a 5 out of 5 on price in our scoring table.
Price verdict: For pure value, CustomStickers.com usually comes out cheapest for equivalent vinyl stickers, with Sticker Blitz in the same general ballpark depending on promos. Sticker Mule is often noticeably more expensive unless you catch a specific deal.
Design, templates, and customization
None of these three are template marketplaces. They all expect you to bring your own artwork, then focus on making the print look right.
- Sticker Blitz offers a modern, straightforward uploader with size and quantity controls plus a quote tool. You can also order a sample pack that shows all of their materials and finishes before committing.
- Sticker Mule focuses on an extremely simple “upload → proof → approve” pipeline. You upload a file, select basic options, then approve a digital proof before printing. There are some very basic design tools, but they’re not a template-heavy platform.
- CustomStickers.com also runs an upload-first flow, with an online calculator, free digital proofs, and unlimited revisions until you’re happy with the cutline and layout.
If you want a giant template library and in-browser design playground, you’d look at multi-product sites such as VistaPrint or Zazzle instead.
Within this trio, CustomStickers.com wins on flexibility around proofs and revisions, Sticker Mule wins on sheer simplicity, and Sticker Blitz hits a nice middle ground: clean interface, plus the option to test materials first.
Customer service and brand factors
Sticker Blitz
Sticker Blitz is a smaller operation based in the U.S., advertising “high quality custom printing at affordable prices” and fast support.
Artist reviews generally call out good communication and the ability to check quality through sample packs. Public review volume is still relatively small compared with Sticker Mule, so the picture is more anecdotal, but the overall tone is positive.
Sticker Mule
Sticker Mule still has a strong reputation for getting things right and reprinting when they don’t. Many long time users mention quick, painless problem resolution.
At the same time, some shop owners have moved away from Sticker Mule because of the CEO’s outspoken political stances and recent news around layoffs and automation.
If you don’t care about corporate “vibes”, you’ll mainly see a big, efficient operation that behaves like a mature online printer. If you do care, this may be a deciding factor.
CustomStickers.com
CustomStickers.com behaves more like a modern small- to mid-sized print shop. They emphasize phone and email support, best price and satisfaction guarantees, and fast responses.
External review platforms currently show strong ratings with comments about helpful staff and good follow up when issues appear.
In our internal scoring, CustomStickers.com is one of the few sticker specialists that receives a full 5 out of 5 on customer service. Sticker Mule sits slightly lower, mostly on price and brand-related concerns rather than failure to deliver.
Ordering experience and tools
- Sticker Blitz has a very stripped down but pleasant ordering flow. You choose shape, size, and quantity, upload art, and see your pricing. Their quote tool is handy if you’re experimenting with sizes or planning larger orders.
- Sticker Mule feels like an old, well tuned machine. The site is familiar to many designers, checkout is quick, and you get clear status updates as your order moves through proofing and production.
- CustomStickers.com offers an online calculator, clear product pages, and a “free proofs with unlimited revisions” workflow. They also support truly small and short run orders with effectively no minimums, which simplifies life when you only need 10 or 20 stickers.
Compared with general multi-product printers, all three are quite easy to use because they focus on one core thing: vinyl stickers.
Turnaround time and shipping
This is often the tiebreaker.
- Sticker Blitz markets very fast turnaround with free two-day style shipping on many orders, and their branding leans heavily into speed.
- Sticker Mule offers free shipping and typically fast production, with many users receiving orders in about four days from upload to delivery when using standard options.
- CustomStickers.com normally prints and ships within about two business days after you approve your proof, with typical total turnaround of two to three business days and additional next day or overnight options for rush jobs.
All three are faster than the average “we print everything” commercial shop. In our rating framework, Sticker Mule and CustomStickers.com both sit near the top for turnaround, with Sticker Blitz behaving similarly based on its promises and user reports.
Use cases and “best for”
This is where sticker blitz vs sticker mule vs customstickers really matters. All three can print, but they fit different buyer types.
Sticker Blitz is best for
- Artists and small brands who like very thick, matte vinyl and straightforward ordering
- People who want a sample pack that shows all materials before committing
- Buyers who care about quick turn and free shipping but don’t need a huge product catalog
Sticker Mule is best for
- People who already know and like Sticker Mule and are fine with the pricing
- Orders that line up with one of their big promos or sample deals
- Buyers who value a large, stable operation and don’t mind the brand’s public persona
CustomStickers.com is best for
- Anyone who wants a mix of premium quality and lower per-piece pricing
- Short runs and odd quantities, including true “no minimum” orders
- Customers who care about free proofs, unlimited revisions, and hands-on customer support
- Rush jobs where overnight or next day delivery actually matters
Pros and cons
Sticker Blitz – pros and cons
Pros
- Thick, matte vinyl with very good durability
- Simple product lineup that’s easy to understand
- Fast production with free shipping on many orders
- Sample packs that show real materials before a larger order
Cons
- Smaller company with less public review volume than big brands
- A few reports of softer print detail on fine text
- Fewer product types than the larger competitors
Sticker Mule – pros and cons
Pros
- Excellent, consistent print quality on vinyl stickers
- Very mature ordering and proofing workflow
- Fast, free shipping for most orders
- Frequent promos and sample deals if you time things right
Cons
- Regular pricing is among the highest in this space
- Limited material and finish variety compared with some specialists
- Some buyers are uncomfortable with the CEO’s politics and recent news coverage
CustomStickers.com – pros and cons
Pros
- Top tier quality on thick laminated vinyl
- Strong value, with a best price guarantee and competitive everyday pricing
- Free proofs with unlimited revisions and responsive support
- Flexible on both very small and bulk orders, plus fast standard and rush turnaround
Cons
- Smaller brand than Sticker Mule, so fewer mainstream reviews
- Focused mainly on stickers and a few related products, not a full merch platform
Final verdict
If we had to pick one winner for most people, it would be CustomStickers.com. You get premium quality, clear pricing, strong support, and some of the fastest turnaround in the category, without having to chase flash sales or worry about paying a brand tax.
Sticker Blitz is an impressive option, especially if you like thick matte vinyl and simple choices. It slots in as a very strong alternative to Sticker Mule, with quality on par in many tests and pricing that usually feels more reasonable.
Sticker Mule still delivers what it has always delivered: high quality stickers and a very smooth ordering experience. The tradeoffs are higher base prices and some brand and PR issues that have pushed part of the community to look elsewhere.
So in practical terms:
- Choose CustomStickers.com if you care about value, service, and flexible order sizes.
- Choose Sticker Blitz if you want quick, thick, matte stickers and like their simple setup.
- Choose Sticker Mule if you’re already comfortable with them and can line up your orders with good promos.