CustomStickers.com Review – Is this Sticker Printing Company Legit?

When you shop for custom stickers online, every site promises “premium” quality and “fast turnaround.” It can be hard to tell who’s actually good and who’s just reselling cheap prints.

CustomStickers.com is one of the newer names that keeps coming up in sticker communities and search results. They claim to make the “highest quality stickers on the planet,” use state-of-the-art equipment, and match competitor prices. They also run aggressive promos like free sticker samples and big quantity deals.

We’ve ordered from CustomStickers.com, followed their growth through their own announcements, and checked external reviews on sites like Trustpilot, BBB, and Reddit. Based on all of that, we’d rate CustomStickers.com 5/5 for what they actually specialize in: custom stickers and labels.

Here’s a detailed breakdown.

What does CustomStickers.com actually do?

CustomStickers.com is a sticker-focused online printer headquartered in Springville, Utah. They specialize in:

• Custom vinyl stickers (their main product)
• Holographic stickers
• Clear stickers
• Waterproof stickers and bumper stickers
• Custom sticker sheets
• Custom labels on rolls
• A growing line of t-shirts and some simple print products

The core of the business is still stickers and labels. That’s where most of their technology, content, and promos are focused.

This is not a general “print everything” site like Vistaprint or UPrinting. If you want brochures, postcards, or a hundred different paper products, you’ll probably go elsewhere. If you care mostly about getting really good vinyl stickers and roll labels, this narrower focus is a plus.

We asked them to throw in a sample pack of their materials so we could see the types of stickers they offer. I have to say, their designs on these are a really fun touch.

Ordering experience and design workflow

Ordering from CustomStickers.com is pretty simple, even if you’re not a print nerd.

For stickers, the flow is usually:

1. Pick a type (vinyl, holographic, clear, sheets, etc.).
2. Choose size and quantity.
3. Upload your art.
4. Get an online proof, request changes if needed, then approve.

They emphasize free online proofs and explicitly say you can request revisions until you’re happy. In their blog they call this out as part of the process: you always see how they’ll cut your design, and you can keep tweaking cutlines, borders, or sizing before anything prints.

On our test orders, proofs came back quickly and reflected the cutline settings we asked for. If you’re used to cheaper sites where the file just “goes straight to press,” this extra step gives some peace of mind.

The site also has a “Sticker Price Calculator,” a decent FAQ, and a blog that explains things like vinyl vs BOPP, how to order, and how to pick the right sticker type for different uses. Overall, the workflow feels clear and beginner friendly without getting in the way if you already know what you want.

Sticker quality and materials

This is where CustomStickers.com leans hard.

Their main custom vinyl stickers are printed on thick, durable vinyl with a laminate on top. They advertise:

• Waterproof and weatherproof performance
• UV-resistant laminate
• Scratch-resistant finish
• 5+ year outdoor life
• Any shape or design via die-cutting

In practice, the stickers we received match that description. The vinyl feels substantial, the laminate is consistent, and cuts are clean even on detailed artwork. Colors are saturated without banding or obvious dot patterns at normal viewing distance.

They apply the same general approach to other lines:

• Holographic stickers use a holographic vinyl with laminate, still rated for multi-year outdoor use.
• Clear stickers rely on clear vinyl, also laminated and weatherproof.
• Sticker sheets use the same basic vinyl stock and kiss-cut designs on a larger sheet.

On the label side, they’ve invested in a serious setup. For roll labels, they’re running BOPP and PET label stocks with matte and gloss laminate, cut on a laser system, and printed on an HP Indigo digital press. That puts them in the same quality class as high-end label houses rather than budget “office label” vendors.

You also see a consistent message about color and detail. The site and product pages talk about having one of the widest color gamuts in the industry, very accurate printing, and laser cutting that can handle complex shapes. From what we’ve seen and from customer feedback, this isn’t just marketing fluff; the stickers hold up at a level that justifies positioning them as premium.

Sustainability and production tech

For a sticker company, CustomStickers.com is unusually transparent about how they print and what they’re doing on the environmental side.

They’ve published blog posts laying out:

• A move to more eco-friendly inks made from natural materials
• Work toward carbon-neutral processing
• Investments in newer, more efficient equipment
• Expanding label production with an HP Indigo press and advanced laser cutter

This doesn’t magically make vinyl “green,” but it does show they’re thinking about waste, energy use, and long-term impact more than many small print shops. For some buyers (especially brands with sustainability goals), that matters.

It’s also a good sign of legitimacy: companies that are actually running serious equipment and facilities tend to talk about it and invest in upgrades, which is exactly what they’re doing.

Pricing and value

CustomStickers.com is not the absolute cheapest sticker printer on the internet. But for what you get, the value is very strong.

Some key points:

• Vinyl stickers are priced competitively with other premium sticker brands, not bargain basement paper labels.
• They run frequent promos and bundle deals (for example, 500 die-cut stickers for a set price, or free sample bundles).
• They offer a best price guarantee for comparable products. If you find a lower price on similar vinyl stickers (same size, quantity, and material), they say they’ll match it.

When you factor in:

• True vinyl with laminate
• 5-year outdoor durability
• Free proofs and revisions
• Free shipping

…the price per sticker is very fair. For cheap bulk paper labels that will sit on indoor boxes, yes, you can find lower numbers elsewhere. For vinyl stickers you expect to live on cars, laptops, and water bottles for years, they’re in a good spot.

Shipping, turnaround, and reliability

CustomStickers.com leans on fast production and free shipping as core features.

On the sticker side, once you approve your proof, they quote very short production times (often 1–2 business days) and then ship via standard carriers. In practice, orders tend to land within about a week in the U.S., often faster, unless you’re way out in the sticks or during peak holiday crunch.

They also ship nationally and list a physical address and phone number on their site. That sounds basic, but it matters when you’re judging whether a company is real or just a middle-man drop shipper.

Between our orders and customer reviews, there’s a consistent pattern: fast turnaround, on-time delivery, and good packaging. It’s not perfect (no printer is), but the hit rate is strong enough that we’re comfortable calling them reliable.

Customer service and reputation

Because this is a relatively young brand compared to the biggest players, you won’t find tens of thousands of reviews yet. But the signals that are out there are positive.

• Their own on-site reviews show thousands of ratings across core products, with lots of specific comments about color accuracy, cut quality, and responsive support.
• On Trustpilot, CustomStickers.com shows up as a “Great” performer with a trust score around 4/5, which is solid in a category where many printers sit lower.
• On the Better Business Bureau site, they have an A+ rating and a clearly listed address and phone number, even though they’re not formally “accredited.” That’s normal; many good businesses never pay for accreditation.
• In sticker communities like Reddit, CustomStickers is frequently mentioned as an alternative to bigger brands. Users call out good customer service, strong print quality, and fair pricing, often in direct contrast to their experience with other companies.

We also see CustomStickers staff answering questions and owning the brand on social platforms. That’s a good sign: scammy or weak operations usually avoid public discussion and stick to anonymous marketplaces.

Pros and cons of CustomStickers.com

Pros

• Excellent print quality on vinyl stickers, holographic stickers, and clear stickers
• True outdoor-durable materials with lamination and multi-year life
• Free online proofs with unlimited revisions and fast response
• Simple ordering flow that works for beginners and designers
• Growing, serious label operation using HP Indigo and laser cutting
• Fast turnaround and free shipping on core products
• Best-price guarantee for comparable vinyl stickers
• Positive signals from BBB, Trustpilot, and sticker communities

Cons

• Product range is focused on stickers and labels; not a one-stop shop for all print products
• Not the absolute cheapest option if all you need is basic indoor paper labels
• Smaller external review footprint than long-established giants (simply because the brand is newer)

None of these cons are dealbreakers if your main goal is to get great stickers. But they’re worth keeping in mind if you’re looking for one vendor to print everything under the sun.

Final verdict: 5/5 for stickers and labels

So, is CustomStickers.com legit?

Based on our own orders, the equipment they run, their sustainability work, and the independent reviews we’ve seen, the answer is yes. This is a real, growing sticker and label manufacturer with serious print capabilities, not a fly-by-night reseller.

If you:

• Want high-quality custom vinyl stickers that last outdoors
• Care about clean cuts, accurate color, and a smooth proofing process
• Prefer working with a specialist rather than a generic “print everything” shop

…then CustomStickers.com earns a full 5/5 from us.

You may still use a big generalist printer for brochures or printed stationery. But for stickers and labels—the core of their business—CustomStickers.com is absolutely worth trusting with your next run.